This is a theme that echoes powerfully through Jewish tradition, and it's something we see vividly in the Devarim Rabbah. This particular passage delves into the profound consequences of both righteous and wicked deeds, exploring how they shape not just individual lives, but the destiny of a nation.
The verse from Proverbs (10:16), "The act of the righteous brings life; the yield of the wicked is sin," serves as the cornerstone of this discussion. It's a simple statement, yet it holds within it a universe of meaning. The Midrash, in its characteristic way, unpacks this verse through stories and interpretations that are both insightful and deeply human.
Take Eliphaz, for example. Rabbi Tanhum points out that Eliphaz, son of Esau, grew up under the influence of his grandfather, Isaac. Because of Isaac's righteousness, Eliphaz refrained from killing Jacob, even when commanded to do so by his father. According to Rashi, this is why Eliphaz does not kill Jacob in Genesis 29:11. "The act of the righteous brings life," indeed. Isaac's influence, even on his grandson from a less-than-righteous lineage, brought about a life-saving act.
Contrast this with Amalek, who, according to the Midrash, was raised in Esau’s lap. The "yield of the wicked is sin," it says. The implication is clear: the environment we create and the values we instill in our children have far-reaching consequences.
But the story doesn't stop there. The Midrash then turns to the reigns of David and Solomon, portraying them as righteous figures whose actions brought life to Israel. And then there's the cautionary tale of Menashe, a king whose actions had devastating consequences.
The text states that Menashe crafted a four-faced idol and placed it in the Kodesh Hakodashim (Holy of Holies) in the Beit Hamikdash (Temple). It was this single act, this bevia (entry), that brought sin upon Israel. It's a powerful image: one wrong decision, one act of defiance, polluting the most sacred space. As Ezekiel 8:5 says, "And behold, north of the gate of the altar was this image of infuriation in the entrance [babia]."
Rabbi Aḥa calls this a biya, "a great cry of injustice for the world," where "the temporary resident ousts the landlord" — the idol displacing God’s Presence. The four faces, corresponding to the four directions and the four beasts bearing God's throne, were designed to attract worship from all corners of the earth.
What was God's response? According to II Chronicles 33:11, God delivered Menashe into the hands of his enemies, the commanders of the army of the king of Assyria, who bound him with fetters. The Midrash elaborates, describing how Menashe was placed in a bronze cauldron and burned. In his distress, he cried out to all the deities he had worshipped, but none answered.
Finally, Menashe turned to the Holy One, blessed be He. He admitted his folly, acknowledging God as the God over all gods. He feared that if God didn't answer him, it would suggest that all beings are alike.
God, according to the Midrash, initially hesitated, recognizing that Menashe deserved punishment. But, unwilling to discourage repentance, God answered his prayer. II Chronicles 33:13 states, "He prayed to Him, and He acceded to his entreaty [vaye’ater lo]." The Midrash cleverly interprets vaye’ater lo as "He excavated on his behalf [vayaḥtor lo]," referencing a tradition that the angels were trying to block Menashe's prayers. God had to literally dig beneath the Throne of Glory to accept his repentance!
Rabbi Shmuel bar Unya, in the name of Rabbi Aḥa, adds that God returned Menashe to Jerusalem with the wind. Only then did Menashe truly acknowledge that the Lord is God.
What are we to take away from this? It's a reminder that our actions, both righteous and wicked, have profound consequences. They shape our lives, the lives of our children, and the destiny of our communities. The story of Menashe, in particular, offers hope. Even the most egregious sins can be forgiven through sincere repentance. And the tale reminds us that God's willingness to forgive is a cornerstone of our faith, a beacon of hope even in the darkest of times.