Elisheba's Four Crowns Collapsed into One Grief

Click for full size

Four Crowns in One Hand

Elisheba, daughter of Amminadab, counted blessings the way other women count loaves. On a single day her brother-in-law Moses stood as a king over Israel. Her husband Aaron was anointed High Priest. Her brother Nachshon was raised as a prince of his tribe. Her two sons, Nadab and Abihu, served as deputies of the priesthood. Four crowns. One woman. The camp still smelled of new oil and fresh linen.

Rabbi Pinchas heard in that hour the hard line from Ecclesiastes: of laughter he said, it is mad. Joy can tangle until the Attribute of Justice seems to laugh even at the righteous. Elisheba held gladness no woman in Israel had ever held so thickly at once. Then her sons stepped forward to bring an offering before the Lord.

They entered in joy. They came out as ash, burned by the fire they had drawn too near. Four crowns collapsed into one grief. Laughter turned to mourning so fast the air still held the scent of anointing when the screaming began.

The Sentence That Waited

Scripture says the sons of Aaron died in the wilderness of Sinai. Rabbi Meir presses the words. Did they die at the mountain? No. At Sinai they were only sentenced. The sentence fell later, at the Tent of Meeting.

He tells of a king marrying off his daughter. On the wedding day the king discovers something foul in his own groomsman, the man trusted to escort the bride. If I strike him now, the king reasons, I darken my daughter's joy. My own celebration is coming. Settle the matter then, not on her day.

So too the Holy One. Nadab and Abihu had earned death already at Sinai. To execute them then would have stained the joy of the giving of the Torah, the wedding of God and Israel. Better, said the Holy One, to wait for My own festival. Song of Songs sings of the day of his wedding and the day of the gladness of his heart (Song of Songs 3:11). The wedding is Sinai. The gladness of His heart is the dedication of the Tent. There the sentence finally fell.

Grief Counted Twice

When the sages weighed the verse that records the death, they found that grief itself can be measured. R. Nahman of Joppa taught in the name of R. Pinhas from R. Simon: the verse sets the death before the Lord, then sets it before the Lord again. Two times before Heaven. Of their father it speaks only once: in the presence of Aaron their father.

One mention for the father. Two for Heaven. The loss cut twice as deep before the Holy One as before their own father. People imagine no one mourns a child as a parent does. Scripture doubles its words and answers otherwise. God grieved the death of the righteous twofold. The bereaved father wept once. The Holy One counted the sorrow twice.

Aaron stood with a silence Scripture itself marks. Elisheba stood with four crowns turned to dust. Between them the camp learned that Heaven's tears can outnumber a parent's without making the parent's tears cheap.

The Eagle and the Nestlings

The sages read the eagle of Job into the heart of the holy service. From there it digs out food; its eyes behold from afar. Just as the eagle scans the world for sustenance, so the High Priest read the year's fortune in the rising smoke of the altar. Smoke leaning south meant plenty in the south. North, west, east, each told its tale. When the column rose straight toward the firmament, the whole world would be fed.

Then the verse turns dark. Its nestlings lap up blood. After all that glory, Aaron beheld his own nestlings, his sons, cooing in their own blood. And he was silent. Where the slain are, there it is: where Nadab and Abihu lay struck down, there too was the Divine Presence.

R. Judan taught in a chain of names: Scripture does not say carry your brothers away from the holiness, but from before the holiness. It is like one who says to his friend, remove the dead from before his father. How long must a father look upon his dead son? For this reason it is written: after the death of the two sons of Aaron.

Ash on the Festival Floor

The dedication day that should have crowned Elisheba became the day Heaven finished a delayed verdict. Sinai's joy was protected. The Tent's gladness carried the cost. Aaron's silence and God's double grief stood on either side of the bodies. The eagle's nestlings drank blood where the smoke had promised grain.

Elisheba's hands, which had held four crowns, held nothing that would not sift through the fingers. Moses still ruled. Nachshon still stood as prince. Aaron still wore the breastplate. Two sons were gone. The Attribute of Justice did not explain itself. It only finished what Sinai had postponed.

Outside the Tent the people still hummed with festival noise. Inside, the Holy One counted sorrow twice, and a mother learned how quickly a single day can turn from coronation into ash.