God Left the World Incomplete So Goodness Could Be Earned

The Soul came in past midnight and would not sit down. She had carried the same objection for years, and standing seemed the only honest way to hold it. "I have learned the commandments and the accounts of the beginning," she said. "Not one of them tells me why I wake every morning into a world somebody left half made."

Click for full size

The Intellect took a pitcher off the shelf and poured her water. He stopped when the cup was half full. Then he set the pitcher on the table between them, close enough that either of them could reach it, and folded his hands.

"Before there was anything, there was nobody to hand anything to," he said. "Good that arrives nowhere is not good given. It is only good kept. So God made someone to stand at the other end of the giving."

She looked at the half cup and left it where it stood.

The Word That Stopped the Sky

He told her what the heavens did at the beginning, and it went like this. They came off the place where they had been laid down like a bolt of cloth off a table with nobody holding the end. They ran. Nothing woven into them was built to catch, and nothing in them had any reason to stop, since whatever set them moving carried no limit anywhere inside it. The seams went out past anything there was to see and kept going.

Then a word came down on top of them. "Dai." Enough. They stopped on the line where the word caught them, and that line is the one still standing over the rooftops. The name Shaddai (שדי) keeps the moment folded inside it, the One who said to His world, enough.

"He could have let them run," the Intellect said. "Nothing outside Him was able to stop them. He stopped them Himself, which is the hardest thing in the world to witness, because it leaves nothing on the ground to point at. A sky that has been held still looks exactly like a sky."

The Bread of Another Man's Table

She wanted a person and not a sky, so he gave her one.

A man sits down to eat in his neighbor's house in a good year. The bread is warm, the neighbor is generous, nothing whatever is wrong with the meal. The man eats with his eyes on the cloth. He answers when he is spoken to and passes what he is asked to pass, and not once in the whole hour does he lift his face to the face of the one who plowed and reaped and baked it, because every crumb in front of him came out of a field he never walked.

"He is not ungrateful," the Intellect said. "He is ashamed, and the shame is accurate. One who eats what is not his own cannot look his benefactor in the face."

Take the same man to the far side of a harvest he worked himself. The bread is worse. He looks up.

What Was Withheld at the Rim

So the making went forward with the power held in. Nothing spilled and nothing ran short by accident. What could have come down whole came down measured, and what came out of it came out deficient on purpose, short by the exact amount a creature could close by working. The lack was cut into the world the way a door is cut into a wall.

"He made them incomplete," the Intellect said. "He wanted the good to reach them in the merit of the effort they spent getting to it. Handed over finished, it would have sat in their hands as that loaf sat in front of that man, and they would have eaten it with their eyes down."

The Soul turned on him. "A world with holes in it is not a kindness. People fall into the holes. Children fall into them."

"They do," he said, and did not soften it. "He held His power back for one purpose, to make the good complete, and complete meant earned. There is no shorter road that ends anywhere near the same place."

The Measure Was Taken From the Creature

The last thing he told her was the strangest, and he told it slowly.

By every rule that runs downward from a maker without limit, the work should have come out without limit, perfection at the first stroke, finished before anyone arrived to touch it. That is what befitted Him. That is not what was done. When the measuring was taken at the beginning, the measure was not His own. It was taken off a creature that did not exist yet. How much light a thing could stand before it went up like straw. How far it could be set from the giver and still keep reaching instead of lying down in the road. Every attribute was cut to the size of a body nobody had made yet.

"He came down to their measure," the Intellect said. "He worked inside a limit He does not have, deliberately, so the ones who were coming would find something left over to do with their hands."

The Soul stood at the shutter a long while with her back to him.

What She Carried Out at Dawn

The room went grey. Through the slats the sky sat exactly where it had been stopped, holding its line above the roofs without any strain in it, as though the word had gone in once and settled and never needed saying twice.

"You poured half," she said.

"I did."

"The pitcher has been in your reach all night."

"In yours as well."

She came back to the table. She stood over the water that was already in the cup, then took the pitcher up in both hands and filled it the rest of the way herself. The water went in without a sound. She drank it standing, the way she had said everything else that night, and went out while the sky held.