5 min read

Joab Had Himself Slung Into Amalek and Sent Blood as His Signal

After six failed months, Joab had himself slung into the Amalekite capital, then sent blood through the gates so Israel could shout the Shema (Hear O Israel).

Curated by Arthur · Told by Maggid ·
Table of Contents
  1. Six Months Against a Wall
  2. A Man Thrown Like a Stone
  3. Shema at the Sight of Blood
  4. The City Taken Clean of Temples
  5. What the Blood Taught the Camp
  6. Forty Days of Not Knowing
Joab Had Himself Slung Into Amalek and Sent Blood as His Signal Click for full size

Six Months Against a Wall

Twelve thousand of Israel's best sat outside the Amalekite capital under Joab and could not break it. Six months of siege. Homes far behind. Children growing without fathers. The soldiers asked to go home. Joab refused the easy road. Retreat would earn contempt. Worse, it would invite every heathen power to pile on a people that quit.

He offered a plan that sounded like madness dressed as command. Hurl him into the city by sling. Wait forty days. If blood flows from the gates, he is still alive. If not, mourn and leave. The general made his own body the reconnaissance, the breach, and the signal fire.

A Man Thrown Like a Stone

They slung him. The wall that had laughed at twelve thousand took one man over its teeth. Inside, Joab was a lone blade in a city of enemies. The legends do not linger on every alley. They linger on the bargain. Forty days. Blood at the gate as proof of life. An army watching wood and stone for a red answer.

Outside, Israel began to mourn him as dead when the days stretched. Grief rose too early. Then the signal came. Blood issued from the city. The watchers' throats changed song in a single breath.

Shema at the Sight of Blood

They cried with one accord, "Hear, O Israel, the Lord is our God, the Lord is One." Blood from an enemy capital became a cue for the unity verse. Not a victory chant of empire. A confession of the Name. Joab mounted a high tower and shouted back in a voice that carried, "The Lord will not forsake his people." Courage jumped the wall the other way. The army demanded permission to storm.

As Joab turned to descend, he saw six verses of a Psalm inscribed on his foot, the first running, "The Lord answers thee in the day of trouble, the name of the God of Jacob is thy defense." Later David would add three verses and complete the psalm. A general's flesh carried draft scripture out of a killing floor.

The City Taken Clean of Temples

Israel took the Amalekite capital. They destroyed the heathen temples inside it. They slew the inhabitants except the king, whom they brought before David with his crown of pure gold still on his head. The siege that six months could not finish ended because one man accepted being ammunition.

Joab's career holds many bodies and many orders. This exploit stands marked as the most remarkable. Not because the kill count was highest. Because the method inverted the usual math of war. The army did not open the city for the general. The general opened the city for the army, with his blood as the telegram.

What the Blood Taught the Camp

Early mourning had been faithless logistics. Blood at the gate corrected it into Shema (Hear O Israel). Joab's tower cry corrected despair into assault. The psalm on the skin corrected the whole scene into prayer under pressure. Amalek is the enemy that finds Israel tired. Joab refused tiredness the right to write policy.

David would later have his reckonings with this same general. The legends do not erase those. They still pause here, at the sling and the forty days and the red gates, to show a commander who spent himself as the price of not teaching the nations that Israel retreats. Twelve thousand waiting. One man inside. A verse on a foot. A crown carried to a king who stayed outside until the work was done.

Forty Days of Not Knowing

The worst hours belonged to the men outside. They had thrown their general like a stone and then had to live with the silence of the wall. No trumpet from within. No messenger. Only the order to watch the gates for blood and the temptation to invent news. On some days they must have told themselves he was already meat. On others they must have told themselves the plan was still working.

Early mourning was a failure of nerve dressed as realism. When the blood finally ran, the Shema corrected the camp's theology as much as its tactics. One God. One people. One more reason not to pack for home. Joab's tower shout, "The Lord will not forsake his people," translated private survival into public doctrine. If the general still breathed inside Amalek, forsakenness was a lie.

The psalm draft on his foot turns the exploit from pure war story into something stranger. Scripture can begin on skin in a killing city. David will finish the lines later in safer air. Composition becomes a relay between a bloodied commander and a king who receives a crown taken from an Amalekite head.

Joab will not always be the hero of his own file. The same legends remember colder orders and a death that seeks the altar. This page stays with the sling. Six months of failure. One impossible insertion. Blood as signal. Shema as answer. A capital stripped of its temples. The cost for tired armies is ugly and clear. Sometimes the only breach left is a willing body, and the only honest telegram is red.

JoabDavidAmalekShemaSiegeWar
← All myths

From the tradition

Sources

2 sources

The texts behind this telling. Some cards carry a translation of the source; others are our own retelling of it, and each card says which. Every card links out to the original.

Legends of the Jews 4:42Legends of the Jews

Retold in our words. Read the original at the link below.The Legends of the Jews by Louis Ginzberg (1909) · Public Domain

He was laying siege to the Amalekite capital. For half a year, twelve thousand of Israel's finest soldiers had been camped outside the city walls, and… nothing.

The soldiers, weary and homesick, approached Joab. "We should go home," they pleaded, "to our wives and children."

Joab was no fool. He understood their longing, but he also saw the bigger picture. Giving up now, he argued, wouldn't just be embarrassing. It would be dangerous. As he pointed out, retreating would invite contempt and derision from their enemies. Worse, it would embolden the surrounding heathen nations to unite against the Israelites. A tactical retreat could turn into a full-blown disaster.

So, what was Joab's plan? It's wild, I promise.

He proposed a truly audacious, some might say insane, solution. "Hurl me into the city with a sling," he declared.

Yes, you read that right. He wanted to be launched over the walls like a human cannonball!

Then, he told them to wait forty days. If, at the end of those forty days, they saw blood flowing from the city gates, it would be a sign that he was still alive.

Now, take a moment to consider that. And imagine the reaction of the soldiers!

This story, found in Legends of the Jews, paints Joab as more than just a general. He's a leader willing to put himself in unimaginable danger for the sake of his people. His plan is so audacious that it seems almost impossible. It's evidence of his unwavering commitment.

What does this tell us? Perhaps that true leadership sometimes requires a willingness to take risks that others wouldn't even dream of. And maybe, just maybe, that sometimes the most outlandish plans are the ones that have the greatest chance of success. After all, who expects a general to ask to be slung into the enemy's capital?

Full source
Legends of the Jews 4:46Legends of the Jews

Retold in our words. Read the original at the link below.The Legends of the Jews by Louis Ginzberg (1909) · Public Domain

Joab was presumed dead, the city was under siege, and then blood began flowing from inside the walls.

The scene: Joab's army is locked in a brutal battle, thousands have fallen. The Israelites, hearts heavy with loss, are starting to believe their general is dead. Then, a miracle. Blood begins to flow out of the city, a sign that their enemies are being vanquished from within.

Hope surges through the ranks. In that moment, unified, they cry out the Shema, the central declaration of Jewish faith: "Shema Yisrael, Adonai Eloheinu, Adonai Echad – Hear, O Israel, the Lord is our God, the Lord is One." (As an aside, "Shema" means to listen, to hear and to obey). This unified declaration, evidence of their unwavering belief, becomes a turning point.

In Legends of the Jews, compiled by Louis Ginzberg, Joab, witnessing this incredible moment, climbs a high tower. With a voice that booms across the battlefield, he shouts: "The Lord will not forsake his people!" This proclamation, filled with conviction, electrifies the Israelite soldiers. They demand permission to storm the city, fueled by renewed courage and faith.

And here's where the story gets even more fascinating. As Joab turns to descend from the tower, he notices something peculiar: six verses of a Psalm are inscribed on his foot! The first verse reads: "The Lord answers thee in the day of trouble, the name of the God of Jacob is thy defense." (This echoes (Psalm 20:2), for those of you who want to look it up). Think about the symbolism here – a message of divine support literally imprinted on the general's very being.

Later, David, recognizing the power of this moment, adds three more verses, completing the Psalm. What was originally just six verses turns into a song of hope and resilience for generations to come.

The result? The Israelites, emboldened by faith and divine signs, capture the Amalekite capital. They destroy the pagan temples, symbols of the enemy's false gods, and vanquish its inhabitants. The only one spared is the king, who is brought before David, still wearing his crown of pure gold. It's a scene of absolute triumph.

What does this story tell us? It's a reminder that sometimes, the most unexpected signs can appear when we need them most, offering guidance and strength. And perhaps most importantly, it highlights the power of collective belief and the enduring promise that, as Joab proclaimed, the Lord will not forsake his people.

Full source