Jonah Was Claimed by Zebulun and Asher Both

Rabbi Levi walked into the hall with two sela in his purse, the Sabbath wage for holding the congregation until Rabbi Yohanan arrived. The benches were already filling. Last week they had chewed Judah's blessing until the words came clear as milk. This week the verse on the table was Zebulun at the shore of seas, a border leaning toward ships and Sidon (Genesis 49:13).

Click for full size

Rabbi Levi Claimed the Harbor

He did not wait for the master. He stood and put a prophet on that shore.

"Jonah was from Zebulun," he said.

The proof had the clean click of a map lining up. Jonah came from Gat Hefer. The boundaries of Zebulun passed through Gat Hefer, a passage eastward named in Joshua, the same town II Kings gives as the prophet's home. Levi set Gat Hefer on the plateaus of Tzippori and sat down with the look of a man whose proof had weight.

The room could smell salt in the blessing. Sails, rope, ports, men who knew weather by the color of morning. A child of Zebulun growing under a blessing of harbors. A prophet who knew the pull of the coast before he knew the command to preach. The ship at Jaffa would not come from nowhere. It would rise from tribal memory.

Rabbi Yohanan Brought the Widow

The next Sabbath, Rabbi Yohanan came and overturned the map.

"Jonah was from Asher," he said.

He did not begin with Gat Hefer. He began along the northern coast, near Sidon, where Asher had failed to drive out the inhabitants of Akko, and where Elijah had been sent to a widow in Zarephath. That widow had a son. In one old telling, the child who passed through death and life in Elijah's arms grew into Jonah the prophet.

If so, Jonah belonged to Asher through his mother's house. He was the child of a woman who had watched her jar of meal refuse to empty and her cruse of oil refuse to fail. He was the son who had stopped breathing and then breathed again because a prophet stretched himself over the boy and cried out to God.

That Jonah would later be swallowed into the deep and returned alive did not feel accidental after that. Before the fish, there was the bed in the widow's house. Before the sea gave him back, breath had once been given back to his body. Rabbi Levi's harbor sat on the bench unused. The master had claimed the mother.

The Third Sabbath Joined the Blood

Two Sabbaths had passed, and the prophet still stood between borders. Zebulun had the map. Asher had the mother. The congregation had heard two good arguments, which is harder than hearing one bad one. Levi came back with his two sela and asked for the hour again.

He did not throw Yohanan's teaching out. He made it larger. Jonah's father was from Zebulun. His mother was from Asher. The father's line gave him Gat Hefer, the harbor blessing, the tribal road toward ships and Sidon. The mother's line gave him the widow's house, the child restored from death, the memory of Elijah's prayer bending over a body until life returned.

He read the verse's border-word as a thigh, the maternal line from which the prophet emerged, leaning upon Sidon. Jonah could belong to both because the life ahead of him would need both. He would need Zebulun's sea and Asher's return from death. He would flee by ship, sink, pray from a place no man chooses, and come back as one already claimed by two inheritances.

The Preacher Sat for Twenty-Two Years

The rabbis listening did not split the difference as a courtesy. They heard a consolation spoken while the man still stood in the hired hour.

"You have spoken words of consolation standing," they told him. "You will come to say them while sitting."

The chair was the prize. Levi took it. He delivered the main discourse for twenty-two years, a long reward for noticing that a person can carry more than one truth in his blood. Other readings of Sidon would come, Zevud of the Galilee, Migdal Deyo, names that moved on a later map. The hall had already settled the prophet.

The hall already knew the rest. God would say go east. Jonah would go west. God would send a storm. Jonah would go down. Under that flight they had found another current. Long before Jonah refused Nineveh, Jacob's blessing and the miracle in Zarephath had already been folded into him. The sailors would see one frightened Hebrew. Heaven would see Zebulun's coast, Asher's widow, Elijah's revived child, and a prophet no border was strong enough to keep from the God who had named him before he ran.

Levi sat. The two sela that had rented an hour had bought a generation of speaking. Jonah, claimed twice, had given him the chair.