5 min read

Joseph's Caravan Carried Spice Instead of Tar

Sold brothers lowered Joseph toward Egypt on camels that should have reeked of pitch. Heaven filled the loads with balsam while Judah drew the secret open.

Curated by Arthur · Told by Maggid ·
Table of Contents
  1. The Pit and the Strange Smell
  2. A Coat and a Double Death
  3. Deep Water and a Long Rope
  4. One Death Only
Joseph's Caravan Carried Spice Instead of Tar Click for full size

The Pit and the Strange Smell

The rope burned Joseph's palms on the way up from the pit. His brothers counted silver. The caravan that took him should have smelled of tar and pitch, the foul cargo camels usually hauled across those roads. Scripture says otherwise. Spice. Balsam. Labdanum. Sweetness where stench belonged.

The Holy One, blessed be He, would not let a righteous man ride into exile inside a cloud of rot. Shall this pious one be set down in the midst of a stench? No. Arrange a good fragrance, that the very air around him testify he is not abandoned. The merchants thought they carried goods. They carried tenderness arranged for a servant Heaven had not released.

Meanwhile Potiphar, who bought him for a baser purpose, was cut off. Scripture names him a eunuch of Pharaoh. The seed of the wicked is cut off, the psalm says, and the midrash hears the severing in the man's very title. Schemes against the pious do not keep their future. The house that meant to use Joseph as a toy finds its own line broken.

Joseph walked between spice bales with wrists still sore from rope. The road south smelled like a kindness he had not asked for and could not yet understand.

A Coat and a Double Death

Far north, Jacob held a bloodied coat and would not be comforted. "I will go down mourning to my son, to Sheol," he cried (Genesis 37:35). The sages heard terror under the grief. He feared dying twice: the death of the wicked in this world and again in the world to come.

God had promised him twelve tribes. One seemed gone. Perhaps he had never merited them. Perhaps he had, and still the arithmetic failed. Either way he saw a double death. So he refused every soft word his other sons offered. Mourning was already a living descent into Sheol (the underworld of the dead).

Neighbors brought food. Wives of sons spoke comfort. Jacob sat as if the floor had opened. The promise of a full household had become a hole with one boy's name on it, and the hole threatened to swallow the father in both worlds at once. He would not eat the comfort. He would not let the hole close with a lie.

Deep Water and a Long Rope

Years later Joseph sat as viceroy, counsel sunk deep as a cistern no one could climb. He tested his brothers with masks and measures, silver cups and hard seats. Force could not reach the bottom of him. Royal clothing is a kind of depth. Dreams remembered are another. The brothers bowed and did not know whom they feared.

Then Judah drew near. Scripture says a man of understanding draws counsel out of deep water. Judah did not leap into the well. He lowered a long rope of words, plea after plea for Benjamin, until they touched the hidden place and pulled Joseph's secret into the light. The royal mask cracked. The brother who sold and the brother who ruled met in the open at last.

Deep water does not yield to shouting. It yields to the one patient enough to keep lowering the rope. Judah became that man in a single long speech that risked his own life for a younger brother's return.

One Death Only

When Jacob finally saw Joseph alive in Egypt, Israel said a strange thing: "Now let me die." Not despair. Relief. When they told him Joseph was dead, he believed he would die in two worlds. Seeing the son living, he received good news that he would die only once.

The spices on the caravan, the severed schemes of Potiphar, Judah's rope of speech, and a father's unclenched terror all answer the same claim: the Lord loves justice and does not abandon His pious ones. They are guarded forever. The road to Egypt reeked of balsam because Heaven was already riding with the slave.

Joseph, who once smelled only the pit, would one day open storehouses and feed a world. The boy sold for silver became the hand that kept mouths alive. Jacob, who once planned a double funeral for himself, walked into Egypt and found that mercy had been planning a different count all along. One death. One reunion. One long road that began with spice where tar should have been.

On the south road the spice dust stuck to Joseph's hair and turned the first nights of slavery into something almost sweet. He hated the sweetness and needed it. The pit had been only earth and brother-breath. This was Heaven's strange courtesy in transit.

In Canaan the bloodied coat stayed folded where Jacob could not stop touching it. Servants stopped offering bread. The house learned the sound of a father who would not be comforted, a low refusal that outlasted every polite visit.

Years on, when Judah's words finally found the cistern of Joseph's counsel, the court chamber felt smaller than the pit had been. Two brothers stood inside a secret that spice and silver and famine had all been preparing without asking either man's leave.


← All myths

From the tradition

Sources

3 sources

The texts behind this telling. Some cards carry a translation of the source; others are our own retelling of it, and each card says which. Every card links out to the original.

Midrash Tanchuma Buber, Vayeshev 14:3Midrash Tanchuma Buber, Vayeshev

Translation of the source text.Midrash Tanchuma (Buber), Public Domain, on Sefaria · CC-BY-SA

Another interpretation of (Ps. 37:28): "For the Lord loves justice [and does not abandon His pious ones; they are guarded forever]." It speaks about Joseph. And where did He guard him? [See] what is written (in Gen. 37:28): "And Midianite traders passed by." And with what were they laden? Is it not the way of camels to be laden only with tar (itran)? Yet here it is written (in Gen. 37:25): "spice (nekhot), balsam, and labdanum." Rather, the Holy One, blessed be He, said: Shall this righteous man be set amid a foul odor? Instead, I will arrange for him a good odor. Thus, "He does not abandon His pious ones." "But the seed of the wicked is cut off" (Ps. 37:28), this is Potiphar, who took him not for labor but for another matter. What did the Holy One, blessed be He, do? He castrated him. Thus, "and the seed of the wicked is cut off," and "cut off" denotes nothing other than castration, as it is said (in Lev. 22:24): "and that which is crushed, smashed, torn out, or cut off [you shall not offer to the Lord]." And whence do we know that he was not a eunuch and the Holy One, blessed be He, castrated him? As it is said (in Gen. 39:1): "Potiphar, a eunuch of Pharaoh."

Full source
Midrash Tanchuma Buber, Vayigash 2:1Midrash Tanchuma Buber, Vayigash

Translation of the source text.Midrash Tanchuma (Buber), Public Domain, on Sefaria · CC-BY-SA

[Another interpretation of (Genesis 44:18): "Then Judah drew near unto him."] This is what Scripture says (Proverbs 20:5): "Counsel in the heart of a man is deep water, but a man of understanding will draw it out." "Counsel in the heart of a man is deep water", this is Joseph. However wise Joseph was, Judah came and prevailed over him, as it is said, "Then Judah drew near unto him." To what is the matter comparable? To a cistern that was so deep that no one was able to go down into it. There came one who was clever, and he brought a great rope and reached its waters and drew up from it. So too Joseph was deep, and Judah came and drew up from him.

Full source
Midrash Tanchuma Buber, Vayigash 10:2Midrash Tanchuma Buber, Vayigash

Translation of the source text.Midrash Tanchuma (Buber), Public Domain, on Sefaria · CC-BY-SA

(Gen. 37:35:) "FOR I WILL GO DOWN MOURNING TO MY SON, TO SHEOL." What is "mourning, to Sheol"? Perhaps I am to die the death of the wicked in this world and in the world to come. Why? Because the Holy One, blessed be He, had promised me that He would give me twelve tribes, and behold, one of them has died. Perhaps I have not merited them, and I am to die in two worlds. Therefore he said, "For I will go down mourning to my son, to Sheol." What is "mourning, to Sheol"? Perhaps I am to die the death of the wicked in this world and in the world to come. Why? Because the Holy One, blessed be He, had promised me that He would give me twelve tribes, and behold, one of them has died. Perhaps I have merited them, yet I am to die in two worlds. Therefore he said, "For I will go down mourning to my son, to Sheol."

Do you wish to know what he said when he saw that he was alive? (Gen. 46:30:) "AND ISRAEL SAID TO JOSEPH: NOW LET ME DIE." And what did he see fit to say, "Now let me die"? Rather, he said: When they came and told me Joseph was dead, I said, "I am to die in two worlds." Now that I have seen that you are alive, I have good tidings that I am not to die, except one time. "Now let me die."

Full source