Rachel Demanded Sons or Counted Herself Among the Dead

Click for full size

Give Me Children or I Am a Dead Woman

Rachel came in from the yard, where her sister's sons were fighting over a stick, and stood in front of her husband with nothing in her arms. "Give me children," she said, "or I am a dead woman."

She was not reaching for a phrase. The Sages held that a person without children is counted among the dead, and they proved it from Hannah at Shiloh, who said that until God gave her a son she had been one of the dead, and that once He gave her a son she was numbered with the living. Rachel had run the same arithmetic on herself. She did not like the column she was in.

Jacob's anger went up like dry brush. "Am I in the place of God, who has withheld the fruit of the womb from you?"

Heaven Called His Answer Wind

The sentence was correct and it was worthless, and heaven said so out loud. A voice answered him with a line out of Job. Should a wise man answer with windy knowledge? The rebuke was not aimed at his theology. It was aimed at a husband who had heard his wife call herself a corpse and had chosen to explain the rules to her.

Then God spoke over Jacob's head, to someone Jacob could not see. By your life, He said, in the same words you have just used, your own son will stand and say it to your children.

Decades later, in Egypt, with his brothers face down on the floor and their father newly buried, Joseph opened his mouth and the sentence came out exactly as Jacob had thrown it, and in his mouth it meant mercy instead of refusal.

Rachel heard none of that. She was still standing in the doorway with her hands empty.

Pray for Me the Way Your Father Prayed

"Isaac did this for your mother," she said. "He stood and prayed for Rebekah, the two of them facing each other across the same silence. Do that. And Abraham, did he not do it for Sarah?"

"Sarah," Jacob said, "brought a rival into her own house."

Rachel heard the price and paid it on the spot. "Then take my maid Bilhah."

He never prayed. He took the maid, and Bilhah conceived immediately, which was an answer and a wound in the same hour. When the boy was born on Rachel's knees she named him Dan, God has judged me, and she meant both halves of the verdict. Judged me and convicted me, because my own body still gives nothing. Judged me and acquitted me, because a son of my household is breathing in this tent.

A second boy came, and she called him Naphtali, from the word for wrestlings, because the wedding canopy had been hers. Every Wednesday she had been dressed and ornamented to go in, and every Wednesday Leah went in instead. Wrestlings with my sister, she said, and I have prevailed. She was naming children the way other people set stones on a boundary line.

Leah Counted the Tribes and Found Her Sister Short

In the other tent, Leah was doing arithmetic of her own. God had settled it with Jacob that twelve tribes would come from him. She had borne six sons. The two maids had borne four. That made ten, and she was carrying the eleventh, and the child in her was a boy.

Which left one place. Leah could see the whole shape of it from where she sat, and she could see her sister standing in a doorway with borrowed sons and no place left in the count.

So Leah, who had taken Rachel's canopy and Rachel's night and Rachel's husband, began to beg for mercy on Rachel's behalf. Let what is in my womb be a girl, she prayed, and do not keep my sister from bearing a son.

The Daughter Who Was Meant to Be a Son

By your life, God answered her, you had pity on your sister. What is in your womb will be a daughter, and she will be remembered for it.

The child was born a girl. Leah called her Dinah, from judgment, because her mother had judged herself out of one more son so that Rachel could have one.

And God remembered Rachel. She conceived, and the birth matched the conception. As there had been no pain in the one, there was no pain in the other. She held a boy who had come out of her own body, and the sentence she had passed on herself in the doorway was struck from the record.

Someone to Blame for the Broken Jar

What she said when she saw him was that God had gathered up her disgrace. She meant it exactly. In a house with no children, disgrace lives in the corners. A jar slips and shatters on the floor and there is no one in the room to fault but the woman standing over the pieces. Now there was a boy, and the boy could be blamed, and being blamed for a broken jar is what belonging looks like from the inside.

Long after, when she was asked by what merit heaven had finally opened her, Rachel did not name her own weeping. She said that many had been with her. Jacob had prayed. Leah had prayed. The woman who had every reason to want her empty had asked for her instead, and that was the ransom that bought her peace.