Parshat Behaalotecha6 min read

The Menorah Moses Could Not Make and God Forged in Fire

Every vessel of the Tabernacle obeyed Moses but one. The menorah broke his hammer, so God cast the raw gold into fire and lifted the lampstand out whole.

Curated by Arthur · Told by Maggid ·
Table of Contents
  1. The One Vessel That Would Not Obey the Hammer
  2. The Finger That Had Taught Him Before
  3. The Gold Cast Into the Fire
  4. The King Who Disqualified His Own Lamps
  5. The Flame Lit for Israel's Sake
The Menorah Moses Could Not Make and God Forged in Fire Click for full size

The One Vessel That Would Not Obey the Hammer

Every other vessel had come out of Moses' hands the way the plans promised. The ark with its carrying poles, the table with its golden rim, the altar, the basin, the boards sheathed in gold. He measured, he struck, he held the work against the vision he had been shown on the mountain, and the metal did what it was told. Then he came to the lampstand, and the metal stopped listening.

Moses turned the design over in his mind the way a man works at a knot he cannot pick loose. One block of gold. No seams, no soldered joints. Out of that single mass he was to raise a central shaft, six branches curving away from it in pairs, and along every branch the cups shaped like almond blossoms, the rounded knobs, the open flowers, every part swelling from the same unbroken metal. Beaten work, hammered from one piece. He struck, and a branch thickened where it should have thinned. He struck again, and a blossom flattened where it should have opened. The hardest labor in the whole Tabernacle, and it was defeating him.

The Finger That Had Taught Him Before

This was not the first thing that had refused to fit inside his understanding. When the laws of clean and unclean creatures were given, he could not hold in his mind which beast a man might eat and which he might not, until the Holy One drew near and showed him with a finger, this hoof and not that one. When the months were handed to Israel, he could not fix in his sight the thin first blade of the new moon, the exact edge of light that opens a month, until again the finger pointed, this is the moon, here the month begins. Twice the human mind had struck a wall, and twice heaven had leaned down through it. The lampstand was the third wall, and it was the highest.

The Gold Cast Into the Fire

So the Holy One gave him an instruction that sounded like surrender. "Take a talent of gold," He said, "and cast it into the fire, and it will be made by itself." Moses lifted the whole weight of it, the gold he had failed to master, and threw it into the flame. Then he stood back from the furnace and spoke. "Master of the Universe, the talent is in the fire before You. Just as You wish, let it be made." And the fire gave it back finished. The base, the shaft, the branches in their pairs, the cups and knobs and almond flowers, all of one piece, raised whole out of the heat by no craftsman's hand. Moses had lifted the hammer only to prove that his hammer could not do it. The command itself had carried the secret from the start, written not as you shall make it but as it shall be made, as though heaven had said all along that no human arm would finish this one.

The King Who Disqualified His Own Lamps

Which left a stranger question underneath the miracle. Why would the Holy One, who is wholly light, want a lamp at all? Darkness is not dark to Him. Night shines for Him like the day. The light dwells with Him and never leaves. A God like that has no need of seven small flames trimmed by a priest.

The answer came as a story about a king and the friend he loved. The king sent word that he would come to dine at his friend's house, so the man made ready what he had, a plain couch, a plain table, a plain clay lamp. Then the king arrived with his whole court, and the servants set down lamps of gold on this side and on that. The friend looked at all that honor and burned with shame, and he gathered up his poor common things and hid them away. "Why is your table bare?" the king asked. "I saw the gold that came with you," the man said, "and I was ashamed of my clay." And the king answered, "By your life, I disqualify every lamp I brought into this house. For the love of you I will burn nothing here but what is yours."

The Flame Lit for Israel's Sake

So it was with Israel. The Holy One, who is light itself, said to them, make Me a sanctuary, hammer Me a lampstand, kindle Me its lamps. And when the work was done and the sanctuary raised, the glory came down so heavy that Moses could not enter the tent. Then the voice called him in, and out of all it might have commanded first, it gave him the smallest thing. "When you kindle the lamps." A God who needs no light, asking for a handful of flames lit by human hands, and disqualifying all the light of heaven to burn only theirs.

Inside the asking was a promise. "If you kindle before Me, I will guard your souls from every evil thing, and nothing evil will touch you. For the soul of a man is My lamp, searching all the chambers of the body." The lampstand that no hammer could forge, that rose finished out of the fire, was never lit to give the Holy One light He already possessed. It was lit so that the hands holding the flame would be kept, and the small light in each of them tended, the way a friend tends the one lamp a king came all that way to see.


← All myths

From the tradition

Sources

2 sources

The texts behind this telling. Some cards carry a translation of the source; others are our own retelling of it, and each card says which. Every card links out to the original.

Midrash Tanchuma Buber, Beha'alotcha 4:1Midrash Tanchuma Buber, Beha'alotcha

Translation of the source text.Midrash Tanchuma (Buber), Public Domain, on Sefaria · CC-BY-SA

[Another interpretation:] WHEN YOU KINDLE THE LAMPS [etc. AND THIS IS THE WORK OF THE MENORAH]. You find that Moses found the work of the menorah more difficult than all the vessels of the Tabernacle, until the Holy One, blessed be He, showed it to him with His finger. So too with the hooves of a clean animal, as it is said, THIS IS THE LIVING THING [WHICH YOU MAY EAT... BUT THIS YOU SHALL NOT EAT] (Leviticus 11:2, 4). So too with the moon, the Holy One, blessed be He, said to him, THIS MONTH (Exodus 12:2). So too with the work of the menorah, as it is said, AND THIS IS THE WORK OF THE MENORAH, HAMMERED WORK OF GOLD [(Numbers 8:4)]. What is "hammered work" (miqshah)? As though to say, how difficult (mah qasheh) it is to make, for Moses labored much before the menorah was made, for thus it says, OF HAMMERED WORK SHALL THE MENORAH BE MADE (Exodus 25:31), [like a person who says, how difficult this work is for me!]. And since it was difficult for him, the Holy One, blessed be He, said to him: Moses, take a talent of gold and cast it into the fire and take it out, and it will be made by itself, [as it is said] (ibid.): ITS BASE AND ITS SHAFT, ITS CUPS, ITS KNOBS, AND ITS FLOWERS SHALL BE OF IT. He would strike with the hammer and it would be made by itself; therefore it is said, OF HAMMERED WORK SHALL IT BE MADE (te'aseh), spelled full with a yod, and not written "you shall make" (ta'aseh), as though to say, it shall be made by itself. What did Moses do? He took a talent of gold and cast it into the fire, and Moses said: Master of the Universe, behold the talent [is cast into the midst of the fire]; just as You wish, let it be made before You. Immediately the menorah came forth made as it should be. Therefore it is written, ACCORDING TO THE VISION WHICH THE LORD SHOWED MOSES, SO HE MADE THE MENORAH (Numbers 8:4). "Moses made" is not written here, but simply "he made." And who made it? The Holy One, blessed be He. Therefore the Holy One, blessed be He, told Moses to warn Aaron [to kindle, as it is said,] WHEN YOU KINDLE. The Holy One, blessed be He, said to Israel: If you kindle before Me, I too will guard your souls from every evil thing, so that nothing evil touches you, for your souls are likened to a lamp, as it is said, THE LAMP OF THE LORD IS THE SOUL OF MAN, SEARCHING ALL THE CHAMBERS OF THE BELLY (Proverbs 20:27).

Full source
Midrash Tanchuma Buber, Beha'alotcha 9:1Midrash Tanchuma Buber, Beha'alotcha

Translation of the source text.Midrash Tanchuma (Buber), Public Domain, on Sefaria · CC-BY-SA

Beha'alotcha. This is what Scripture says (Psalms 139:12): "Even darkness is not dark to You, [and night shines as the day; the darkness is as the light]." Yet You say to us, "When you set up the lamps" (Numbers 8:2)? To what is the matter comparable? To a king who had a beloved friend. The king said to him: Know that I will dine at your house, so make ready for me. His friend went and prepared a commoner's couch, a commoner's lamp, and a commoner's table. When the king came, his servants came with him, and they set before him on this side and on that side lamps of gold. When his friend saw all this honor, he was ashamed, and he hid away everything that he had prepared, for it was all of a commoner's sort. The king said to him: What is this? Did I not say to you that I would dine at your house? Why have you prepared nothing for me? His friend said to him: My lord the king, I saw all this honor that came with you, and I was ashamed, and I hid away everything that I had prepared for you, because they are a commoner's vessels. The king said to him: By your life, I disqualify all the vessels that I brought with me, and for the sake of your love I desire to use nothing but what is yours. So too the Holy One, blessed be He, is wholly light, as it is said (Daniel 2:22): "and the light dwells with Him." And He says to Israel: Prepare for Me a menorah and lamps. What is written there? "And let them make Me a sanctuary" (Exodus 25:8), "and you shall make a menorah of pure gold" (Exodus 25:31). When they had made it, the Divine Presence came. What is written there? "And Moses was not able to enter the Tent of Meeting" etc. (Exodus 40:35). Immediately He called to Moses, "and when Moses came into the Tent of Meeting to speak with Him" (Numbers 7:89). And what did He speak to him? "When you set up the lamps." By your lives, for the sake of your beloved devotion I disqualify everything, and I use what is yours: "When you set up the lamps."

Full source