Parshat Beshalach6 min read

Twelve Springs and Seventy Palms at Elim Rehearse Israel

Parched Israel reaches Elim and the elders count twelve springs and seventy palms, then read the oasis as their own future drawn in water and shade.

Curated by Arthur · Told by Maggid ·
Table of Contents
  1. The Elders Walked the Oasis and Began to Count
  2. A Fountain for Each Tribe, a Tree for Each Elder
  3. Why a Spring and Not a Cistern
  4. The Heart of the Palm Soars High
  5. The Camp They Left Behind

The water at Marah had been bitter, and three days of dry wadi had followed it. Now the children of Israel came over a rise of cracked clay and stopped where they stood. Below them the ground turned green. Palms stood in a loose crowd, their crowns moving a little in the heat, and between the trunks the light broke into pieces on standing water.

No one gave the order to run. The flocks smelled it first and pulled their herders down the slope, and then the whole camp poured after them, waterskins flapping empty against their backs. Men knelt at the first pool and drank with their faces in it. Women filled jars and carried them back up the slope to the old and the sick who could not run. The place had a name already. They called it Elim.

The Elders Walked the Oasis and Began to Count

When the first thirst was broken, the elders of the tribes went out among the trees, the way men do who cannot rest until they understand a thing. They walked the edge of the green and they counted the springs. Not many. Not few. Exactly twelve.

An old man of Judah stood at the rim of one pool and was quiet for a long time. Twelve, he said. As if the desert had measured them. Someone laughed at him, tired and easy, and asked what the springs cared for the tribes of Jacob. The old man did not laugh back. He walked to the next spring, and the next, and at each one he set a stone, until twelve stones marked twelve fountains, and the count would not come out otherwise no matter how often a man redid it.

Then they counted the palms. The trees were harder, scattered and leaning, but the elders went tree to tree across the whole of Elim, and when they had finished they stood very still. Seventy. Seventy palms, and not one more.

A Fountain for Each Tribe, a Tree for Each Elder

The numbers were too clean to be nothing, and the old man of Judah said so. Twelve springs for the twelve sons of Jacob. Seventy trees for the seventy who would one day bear the weight of the people with Moses. He spoke it before any such seventy had been chosen, before Moses would ever stand and say he could not carry this people alone, but the elders heard it and did not argue, because the ground had said it first.

So they divided the water. This spring to Reuben, that one to Simeon, the third to Levi, around the whole oasis until every tribe had a fountain of its own. No tribe was sent to drink at another's pool. Reuben would not water where Judah watered. Each house came to its own spring and drank, and the camp that had arrived as one desperate crowd settled into twelve circles of firelight, each beside its own water, all of them inside the same ring of trees.

Why a Spring and Not a Cistern

A man of Issachar asked why the sign was springs and not wells, since a well a man digs and a spring God opens. An elder answered him with his hand on a palm trunk. A cistern holds what was poured into it, he said, and gives back only that, and goes dry. A spring is fed from beneath. It rises on its own and does not stop rising.

A tribe that is righteous, the elder said, is a spring and not a cistern. It does not give back only what was poured into it. It bubbles up from underneath, deed after deed, and the more it gives the more it has. So twelve springs, and not twelve filled jars. The desert had not handed Israel a ration. It had shown them what each tribe could become, water that does not run out because the source is below the ground and not in the jar.

The Heart of the Palm Soars High

That left the trees, and the seventy who were the trees. The man of Issachar looked up at the crowns far over his head and asked why the elders should be palms and not cedars, which are taller, or oaks, which are stronger.

Because of where its life sits, the elder told him. Cut into most trees and the living part is the wood down near the root, close to the dirt that fed it. But the palm keeps its life up in the crown, a single soft heart tucked high among the branches, guarded on every side like a queen behind her ranks. Lose that heart and the whole tree dies, tall as it is. The palm's life does not lie down in the ground. It rises and rests at the top.

That is the soul of a man who has tasted true piety, the elder said. It learns to look upward. The things of the dust become a child's game to it, and only the beautiful and the high feel like serious work. A leader of Israel must be a palm. His root may be in the earth like every other man's, but his heart must sit up in the light, where the wind moves it and the dirt cannot reach.

The Camp They Left Behind

They stayed at Elim by the water, twelve fountains and seventy palms, and when the cloud lifted and the trumpets called them back into the sand, they went. The springs did not follow them. The trees stayed rooted where they were.

But the old man of Judah looked back from the rise where they had first stopped, and he saw the whole green ring laid out below, the twelve pools catching the last light, the seventy crowns standing watch over them. He had seen this shape before its time. Twelve portions of a land not yet given, with shared borders and separate waters. Seventy heads to carry one people. The desert had drawn the future of Israel in water and in shade, and then let them walk away from it, carrying the picture in their heads toward a country that did not yet exist.


← All myths

From the tradition

Sources

2 sources

The texts this telling draws on, in full. Open a card to read inline, or expand it for a wider, quieter read.

Targum Pseudo-Jonathan on Exodus 15:27Targum Pseudo-Jonathan on Exodus

Targum Pseudo-Jonathan on (Exodus 15:27) reads the stopover at Elim as a map of Israel's constitution: And they came to Elim; and in Elim were twelve fountains of water, a fountain for each tribe; and seventy palm-trees, corresponding with the seventy elders of Israel: and they encamped there by the waters.

Twelve fountains for twelve tribes. Seventy palms for the seventy elders. The Targumist refuses to let these be coincidence. The desert had arranged itself for the shape of Israel's future governance.

The seventy elders will appear by name a few chapters later, when Moses cannot judge the people alone (Exodus 18). They will return in Numbers 11, when the Holy One takes the spirit from Moses and distributes it among them. Seventy is the number of the Sanhedrin, the rabbinic high court that would preside over Jewish law until the Roman destruction of the Second Temple in 70 CE.

Twelve is the number of tribes. Each tribe gets its own fountain because each tribe will develop its own relationship to Torah. Reuben will not drink where Judah drinks. Each will need water of its own. The Targum is telling us that Jewish peoplehood is not a uniform crowd. It is twelve distinct fountains, each feeding a tribe, all within the same oasis.

The Maggid hears in this the deep wisdom of the Jewish tradition. Unity is not uniformity. The land of Israel will eventually be divided among the tribes in exactly this pattern, twelve portions with shared boundaries. The governance will be delegated among seventy elders, shaded by the same palms.

Takeaway: a healthy community has many fountains, not one. It has many shade-givers, not one. Elim was not a rest stop. It was a blueprint.

Full source
Legends of the Jews 1:82Legends of the Jews

They weren't just seeing the world; they were reading it like a sacred text. They saw more than just a landscape; they saw a mirror reflecting the destiny of their people.

What did they see, exactly? They saw a land blessed with springs. These springs reminded them of the twelve tribes of Israel. Each tribe, if righteous, would be like a "well of water," constantly bubbling forth with good deeds. Piety, wasn't just a feeling; it was an active force, a source of endless blessings. Ginzberg retells this idea in Legends of the Jews, drawing from earlier traditions.

Then there were the leaders, the seventy elders. They were different. They were like a noble palm tree. Now, the palm tree wasn't just any tree. It was considered the most beautiful of trees, majestic in its appearance and abundant in its fruits. But the real magic, according to this ancient interpretation, lay in where its life force resided. Unlike other plants whose life is rooted deep in the ground, the palm tree's life center "soars high," nestled like a heart amidst its branches, protected like a queen by her guards. It's a powerful image!

What does this have to do with leadership? Well, the palm tree represents the soul of someone who has tasted true piety. This soul, like the palm tree's heart, has learned to look upward, to ascend. It is constantly engaged with spiritual matters, seeking out the beauty of the Divine. Earthly things? They seem like mere child's play in comparison. Only the pursuit of the spiritual, that aspiration, feels truly serious and important. It's a beautiful analogy, isn't it?

This idea of ascending to spiritual heights appears throughout Jewish mystical thought. The Zohar, for example, often speaks of the soul's journey upward. And as we find in Midrash Rabbah, the idea of seeing symbols and meaning in the natural world was widespread.

So, the next time you see a tree, or a wellspring, remember this ancient interpretation. Remember the wise elders who saw in nature a reflection of their community's potential. Remember the call to look upward, to seek out the Divine, and to let that spiritual aspiration guide our lives. What if we, too, could learn to see the world not just as it is, but as it could be, brimming with meaning and potential for goodness? What beautiful deeds might we then be inspired to bring forth?

Full source