The Five Sins Esau Committed While Abraham Was Buried
The day Abraham died, Esau came home starving and sold his birthright for soup. The rabbis say that was the least of what he did that afternoon.
Table of Contents
What Jacob Was Cooking and Why
The morning Abraham died, Jacob was in the tent cooking lentils. He was not cooking for himself. He was cooking for Isaac, his father, who was mourning. Lentils were the food of mourning in Jewish tradition, their round shape representing the cycle of life and loss, their sealed surface standing for the silence a mourner maintains. Jacob, the son who stayed home, who tended the camp and learned from his father while Esau hunted, was performing an act of consolation.
This is the context Targum Jonathan, the expansive Aramaic translation of the Torah composed in the early centuries CE, supplies for a scene the Torah presents without background. Jacob was sitting with his grieving father when Esau came in from the field. And what Esau did next, the exchange that lasts barely forty words in the Hebrew text, was only the last item on a list that had been accumulating since dawn.
Five Sins Before Sunset
The rabbis counted them. On the day his grandfather was buried, Esau committed five transgressions.
He violated a betrothed woman. He murdered a man. He denied the resurrection of the dead, saying directly that a man lives and then is gone, that the promise of return was a lie. He denied God's existence, dismissing the divine framework that his family had built their entire lives around. And he sold his birthright, the inheritance of the covenant, the spiritual legacy of Abraham and Isaac, for a bowl of lentil soup because he was hungry from the exertion of the previous four sins and could not think past his own stomach.
Bereshit Rabbah, the foundational midrashic collection on Genesis compiled in the Land of Israel in the fifth century CE, does not separate the stew from the rest. The round lentil on the fire was a symbol of the cycle: life turns, loss comes to everyone, the world goes around. Esau, who had just denied that the cycle meant anything, who had spent the morning murdering and violating and rejecting the promises his grandfather had died holding, now stood in his father's tent demanding to be fed. And Jacob, watching all of this, named his price.
What Abraham Saw Before He Died
Targum Jonathan adds a detail about Abraham's death that changes how the whole scene reads. God shortened Abraham's life by five years. Abraham was supposed to live to one hundred and eighty. He died at one hundred and seventy-five. Why? So that he would not live to see what Esau became.
This is a mercy that functions as a judgment. Abraham, who had pleaded with God to spare Sodom, who had loved his grandchildren and welcomed them into his household, was spared the knowledge of what his grandson was doing on the day of his burial. God removed him before the evidence arrived. That removal was both a gift to Abraham and an indictment of Esau: the grandson was bad enough that God edited the patriarch's life to protect him from the information.
Why Esau Scorned the Birthright
Genesis 25:34 says it plainly: he ate, he drank, he arose, he went, and Esau scorned the birthright. The Midrash zeroes in on the word scorned. Not sold. Not traded. Scorned. Esau did not make a reluctant transaction under pressure. He held the covenant of his grandfather in contempt. He looked at the promise that had sustained Abraham through Ur and Canaan and Egypt and Moriah, the promise that had cost Isaac the altar and Jacob twenty years in exile, and he dismissed it as worth less than dinner.
The Book of Jubilees extends the picture further. After Isaac died, it records, Esau's sons heard that Jacob had received the portion of the firstborn from Isaac's blessing and came immediately to contest it. The family argument that began at the lentil pot continued into the next generation, the sons inheriting the father's grievance long after the day of the five sins had passed into legend.
← All myths