God Showed Moses the Spring Where Justice Looked Like Cruelty

Click for full size

The Lawgiver's Complaint on the Mountain

Forty days inside the cloud, with the tablets still uncut, Moses could not swallow the question any longer. He had watched the road that led him up to Sinai. A widow left to bury her own dead. A liar grown fat on other men's fields. A gentle man buried young while the one who cursed him kept climbing.

"Show me Your ways," he said into the fire. "Why does one honest man eat and another starve? Why does one wicked man fall and another rise? Master of the world, let me see the law by which You rule it."

The voice on the mountain did not defend itself. It opened a window in the air and told him to look down.

The Spring at the Foot of the Rock

Below him a spring ran out of a rock into a stone basin, the way water runs anywhere men and animals gather. A traveler rode up, dropped from his horse, knelt, and drank until his beard streamed. When he stood he left behind a purse heavy with gold, forgotten in the grass. He mounted and rode north without a backward glance.

A boy came next, driving a goat to water. He saw the leather purse lying in the grass, weighed it in his palm, felt the coins shift, and ran. He did not look back either.

Then an old man came to the spring with an empty jug, lowered himself onto the stone, and drank.

The Purse, the Boy, and the Dead Man

The traveler returned at a gallop, his face white. He had felt the weight gone from his belt. He found the old man alone at the water and saw no one else, and something in him tore loose. "Thief," he shouted. "Give it back." The old man lifted his wet hands, empty, and swore he had touched nothing but the spring. The traveler did not wait. He drew, and he struck, and the old man folded over the stone basin, and the clear water went dark and then red.

Moses turned his face from the window. "This is Your law?" he said. "The boy runs off rich. The old man dies for a coin he never saw. The killer rides home clean. Master of the world, I would rather not have looked."

The Ledger No Living Eye Was Meant to Read

Then God unrolled the account beneath the scene, the part no living eye is built to read.

The gold in that purse had never belonged to the traveler. Years before, in another town, he had robbed it from the boy's father, coin for coin, and left that house poor. The boy who snatched the purse from the grass had carried off nothing but his own. And the old man bleeding on the stone was no innocent stopping for water. In his youth he had murdered the traveler's father and walked away, and no court had ever found him. The traveler, riding blind with rage, had at last avenged a father he barely remembered, and paid a debt he never knew he carried.

Three men at one spring, and every stroke of it had closed an old account. Measure answered measure, the same reckoning that would one day thicken the Nile into blood because Egypt had fouled the water of Hebrew slaves. Nothing at the spring was cruelty. It was arithmetic run across three lifetimes, and Moses had been shown only the middle line.

The Faces That Had Not Been Born

The window widened. Now the generations still unborn crowded into the light, rank on rank: the interpreters bent over letters he had not yet carved, the prophets, the judges, the quiet pious ones no chronicle would name. He watched a righteous man promised rest and then stripped of it. Whenever such a man leaned toward a season of peace, the Accuser rose in the court above and argued that a soul already promised the world to come had no claim on comfort in this one. Even Jacob, who had begged heaven for nothing but to sit still at last, had heard that voice at his door and lost Joseph the moment the road seemed to smooth.

Then God showed him the far edge of the account. Above the earthly sanctuary Moses was commanded to build, another was rising, raised by no human hands, a house of jewels and pearls and the light of the Shekhinah (the Divine Presence), kept for Israel to the end of all the generations he had just watched file past. The ledger that looked like slaughter at the spring came out even there, in a Temple that would never fall.

Moses pressed once more. "Teach me the whole of it," he said.

"You cannot hold all the rules by which I govern the world," the voice answered, "but take one. When a man comes to Me with no claim, nothing owed him for his own deeds or his fathers', and still he begs and will not stop, I answer him, and I give him what he needs."

The window shut. Below the mountain the spring still ran out of the rock into the basin, clear again, catching the light, telling no one what it had balanced. Moses gathered the tablets and started down toward the people who would ask him, in every generation, the same thing he had asked, and to whom he could carry back only the single line he had been given.