Joseph's Steward Accused the Brothers of Repaying Good With Evil

Click for full size

The Sentence Judah Carried Home

The sacks were light again, and Judah had to say it out loud a second time in front of his father. "The man attesting attested to us. You shall not see the sight of my face unless your youngest brother be with you."

Attesting attested. Not a warning. An oath, doubled the way a court doubles a word to make it hold. Jacob said nothing for a long moment, and into that silence the brothers began defending themselves. "The man demanding demanded about us and about our family. Is your father yet living? Have you a brother? We told him what there was to tell. Could we know he would say, bring your brother down?"

Demanding demanded. The Egyptian had not been making conversation. He had gone through their household name by name, like a man counting sheep he already owned. Reuben had tried to move the old man once and failed. Judah put his own body up as the surety instead, and Jacob, with the last of the grain on the floor of the tent, let Benjamin go.

Bread in Every City

They went down the way everyone went down. Through the seven good years the produce had been gathered under Pharaoh's superintendents and set in the cities to be kept, so that what grew near a city stayed near that city. No single vault held Egypt's life. Every town on the road had its own doors and its own guards, and one man's order stood behind all of them.

Joseph had been in a pit once with nobody near enough to hear him. He had built a country where nobody would be more than a walk from bread. His brothers rode past those granaries for days without once asking whose hand had filled them.

Peace to You, Said the Steward

At the house they pushed the silver forward before anyone could accuse them of holding it. Every man's money had come home in the mouth of his own sack the last time, and they had carried it back down in their hands the whole way, like men transporting the evidence against themselves.

The steward would not take it. "Peace to you," he said. "Be not afraid of my lord. Your God and the God of your fathers gave you treasure in your sacks. Your money came to me."

Your God and the God of your fathers. An Egyptian house, an Egyptian officer, and out of his mouth came the phrase a Hebrew child learns at his grandfather's knee. His name was Menasheh, and Joseph had set him over the household. Nobody in the room did the arithmetic.

Then he went into the back and brought out Simeon, held there since the last trip. Simeon came into the light thinner than he had gone in, and his brothers breathed. They washed. They were seated by age, in an order no stranger in Egypt had any way of knowing, and they ate a good meal in the house of a man who was studying them over the rim of a cup.

Why Have You Returned Evil for Good

They had not gone far from the city. The donkeys had not settled into the road yet.

Behind them Joseph turned to Menasheh, whom he had appointed intendant of his house. "Arise, follow after the men. Overtake them and say to them, why have ye returned evil for good?"

The steward closed the distance and put the accusation into their backs at full voice. Why have you returned evil for good. Ten grown men stopped in the road with the dust still coming up around them, and the charge named a theft not one of them could account for.

The Question Nobody Asked at the Pit

It was the wrong crime and the right question. A steward on a horse had just accused them of repaying good with evil, and those words had been waiting twenty-two years for a mouth that would say them where the brothers had to stand and hear it.

A boy had kept his father's flock and carried word between the tents and walked out to Dothan alone because his father asked him to. They had answered that with a cistern, a torn coat dipped in blood, and a price in silver. Nobody had stood in front of them that afternoon and asked why. The question had gone into the ground with him.

Now it came up the road from behind, in Egyptian, from a steward they could not see was their nephew, on behalf of a man they could not see was their brother. Judah heard it. Simeon, three days out of a cell, heard it. Benjamin, who had not been born into any of it, heard it beside them.

They lowered every sack to the ground there in the road to prove themselves innocent, and while their hands worked at the ropes the sentence kept going around behind their ribs. Evil for good. Evil for good. Behind them the grain sat in its local vaults in every city, exactly where one man had ordered it kept, and the famine that had driven them down into Egypt had walked them to within arm's reach of the only person alive with the right to ask.