Retold in our words. Read the original at the link below.138 Openings of Wisdom, trans. Rabbi Avraham Greenbaum, Azamra Institute (2005) · CC-BY
Is it a force from outside, an external demon tempting us? Or is it something...else? Jewish mystical tradition, particularly in texts like Kalach Pitchei Chokhmah (Forty-Four Openings of Wisdom), delves deep into this very question. It's a journey into the subtle architecture of creation itself, and it might surprise you.
Judgment – din in Hebrew – is often remembered as a negative thing. But in Kabbalah, judgment is a necessary force. It's the principle of limitation, of definition. It's what allows things to be distinct, to have boundaries. But what happens when that judgment becomes..excessive?
Kalach Pitchei Chokhmah tells us that the judgment revealed in what's called the "Residue" wasn't potent enough to actually cause the Other Side – that is, the realm of negativity, of evil. Think of it like this: a little bit of restriction, a little bit of "no," isn't inherently bad. It can even be protective. But too much? That can lead to a whole different ballgame.
That's why, the text explains, we only find a true "root" of evil when we get to the world of Nekudim. Now, this is where it gets interesting. Before Nekudim, there was Akudim. These are stages in the emanation of the divine light, stages in the unfolding of creation. In Akudim, the light – the divine energy – was primary. There was a "vessel," a container for that light, but it was completely subservient to it.
But then came Nekudim. And here's the key: "the root of evil lies in the vessels." Just like the body depends on its organs, the vessel is the cause of the body. In Nekudim, the vessels – the containers – started to assert themselves. They became differentiated, distinct. They took control.
Why is this significant? Because, in Akudim, even though a vessel existed, it didn't "rule." It was just one unified vessel with ten lights. It hadn’t yet become differentiated. Think of it as potential energy, a seed that hasn’t yet sprouted. It wasn’t yet called a root to the Other Side. But as soon as it became revealed in all its constituent details and took control – namely, in the world of Nekudim – it reached a suitable level for that potential to actualize.
Imagine a perfectly balanced ecosystem. Everything is in harmony, light is dominant. Now imagine introducing a foreign element, something that disrupts the balance, that starts to take over. That's kind of what happened in Nekudim. The vessels, the containers, became too prominent, too controlling. And that's when the potential for imbalance, for negativity, for what we call "evil," really took root.
So, what does this all mean? It suggests that evil isn't some external force, some demon lurking in the shadows. It's an imbalance within the system, a distortion of the natural order. It's when the containers, the limitations, become more important than the light they're supposed to hold.
And isn't that a powerful lesson for our own lives? When we get too caught up in our own limitations, our own fears, our own rigid structures, aren't we creating the conditions for imbalance, for negativity, to take hold? Perhaps the key, then, is to always remember the light, to strive for balance, and to keep our vessels – our ego, our desires – in their proper place, as containers for the divine spark within.
Click for full size
