The Seven Souls Barred From the World for Evil Speech

Bent over the benches, the sages counted the seven souls who would never rise. Three kings first. Jeroboam, who set golden calves at Dan and Bethel. Ahab, who fed the prophets of Baal at his own table. Manasseh, who filled Jerusalem with blood. Named, sealed, shut out of the world to come.

Click for full size

Then a hand reached for a fourth crown.

Solomon. The wisest of men, builder of the Temple, in old age a lover of foreign women who turned his heart after their gods. The verse lay open on the table. "Solomon did what was evil in the eyes of the LORD." A fourth king. The pen was ready.

The Fire That Came for Solomon's Name

A voice broke from heaven. "Touch not My anointed ones." The sages froze and set down the pen. But the verse would not close. Solomon had sinned, and the law is the law. One day they returned to write his name among the damned. Fire came down from the sky and scorched the wood where they sat. The voice came again, harder now. "Should He repay it as you would, because you have refused?" Still they pressed, because it stood written that the king had done evil, and a court does not flinch from a verse.

The Four Whose Tongues Buried Them

If the kings could hide behind their crowns, the four commoners had nothing. Balaam, Doeg, Ahitophel, and Gehazi. The sages looked closer. These four were not thrown out for idols or for blood, but for evil speech, each buried by his own tongue.

Balaam went down first. He had stood among the exalted, in the partition of the patriarchs. Then he opened his mouth to curse Israel for a Moabite king's gold, and the same mouth carried him down. "From Aram Balak has brought me," he said, and brought me means only the road down to Gehinnom (the realm of judgment after death).

Doeg the Edomite came next. When David fled from Saul to Nob, the city of priests, Ahimelech the high priest fed him and put a sword in his hand. Saul, half-mad, gathered his servants. "Not one of you uncovers my ear." Then Doeg, who had watched it all, stepped forward and spoke. By the time his words landed, eighty-five priests who wore the ephod lay dead, and Nob was put to the edge of the sword. One tongue emptied a city.

Ahitophel gave the finest counsel in Israel, sought like the word of God. When Absalom would not follow it, Ahitophel rode home, set his house in order, and hanged himself. The mouth that ruled kings turned on the man who owned it.

Gehazi served the prophet Elisha. When Naaman the Aramean, cleansed of his leprosy, pressed silver and gold and garments on Elisha, the prophet refused every coin. Gehazi watched the treasure walk away. "My lord has spared this Naaman," he muttered, and ran after the Aramean for a share. He took idolater's silver. Elisha met him at the door. "The leprosy of Naaman shall cleave to you and to your seed forever." Gehazi walked out white as snow.

The Covenant Written on the Leper's Skin

Then Rabbi Pedat named the law running under all of it. A covenant was cut by the Holy One at the world's founding, he said, that whoever speaks lashon hara is struck with leprosy. The opening verse of the whole matter lay before them. "This shall be the law of the leper." The leper, in the Hebrew, is ha-metzora. Broken open, the word splits into ha-motzi ra, the one who brings forth evil. The skin does not lie. The white blossom on the arm is the mouth's own sentence made flesh.

The Scholars Who Knew Every Face of the Law and Fell

Rabbi Joshua of Sikhnin told the other half in the name of Rabbi Levi. In David's day there were children who had not yet tasted sin, able to turn a single law through forty-nine faces to declare it pure and forty-nine to declare it impure. David prayed over them. "You, O LORD, will keep them," guard their Torah in their hearts, keep them from a generation ripe for ruin.

And still they marched out to war and fell in the field. Brilliant, clean in the law, and dead. David knew the reason. "My soul is in the midst of lions," he sang. Abner and Amasa were lions in the Torah. But among them lay men aflame after slander, Doeg and Ahitophel once more. The men of Keilah, whom David had rescued, schemed to hand him back to Saul. The Ziphites climbed to Saul with word, "Is not David hiding among us?" Teeth like spears, tongues like drawn swords. David could not stand in that camp. "Be exalted above the heavens, O God," he cried, lift Your Presence up and away from them. Torah in every mouth, and slander in just enough of them to lose the war.

The Idolaters Who Guarded Their Mouths and Won

Turn to the house of Ahab, and the whole accounting flips. Every man in that generation bowed to idols. And they marched out to war and won. While Jezebel hunted the prophets, Obadiah hid a hundred of them in caves and carried them bread and water through the drought. Then Elijah stood on Mount Carmel and cried, "I alone am left a prophet of the LORD." Every man on that mountain knew he was not alone. They knew the hundred prophets breathing in the dark. Not one of them carried the word to the king. A whole idolatrous nation held a deadly secret. No informer. No whisper. And when they took the field, they came home alive.

On Mount Carmel a nation of idol-worshipers kept its tongue still and lived. In David's camp the finest minds in Israel opened forty-nine faces of the law and lay dead in the field, because a handful could not keep silent.