Moses Withheld Simeon's Blessing and Hid It Inside Judah

The tribes leaned toward the slope of Moab as if a name could be caught in the air. Moses was dying. He had come down from the tent with lamp-oil still on his fingers, the river at his back, the camp spread before him like a field that had to be spoken over before it could be left.

Click for full size

He began with Reuben, then Judah, then Levi, Zebulun in his tents, Issachar at his books, Gad like a lion, Dan a whelp leaping from Bashan. Mothers held their sons by the shoulders so the words would land on the next generation too.

Eleven Names Leave His Mouth

A man near the front counted on his fingers, because he had a habit of it: Reuben, Judah, Levi, Benjamin, Joseph, Zebulun, Issachar, Gad, Dan, Naphtali, Asher. Eleven. His thumb hung in the air with nothing left to fold.

Where was Simeon?

The Simeonites stood in a tight knot to one side, waiting for the syllable that would carry their name up the way every other name had gone. Moses's mouth kept moving. Naphtali, satisfied with favor. Asher, dipping his foot in oil. Joseph's name came out of him with tears in it. Theirs did not come out at all.

A curse, at least, names a tribe, but this did not. The man who had thrown himself down to stop fire and plague, who had argued forty years with heaven on their behalf, had reached Jacob's second son and gone quiet. If he had forgotten, someone would have called the name up to him, but no one did, so the gap sat in the air until it had weight.

The Tents at Shittim Still Burn

It was not forgetfulness. Moses could not forget. Behind his eyes the camp at Shittim was still on fire.

He still saw the men slipping out at dusk toward the Moabite tents. Women waited there with wine and bright cloth and a bow before another god. Israel gave itself away for a night, and then the plague walked the rows and took twenty-four thousand before Phinehas drove a spear through the worst of it and the dying stopped (Numbers 25:9).

When the dead were sorted tribe by tribe, Simeon's dead were not a share but a flood. The Simeonites had not been pulled along at the back. They had led the others down into those tents. Moses had carried that count across the wilderness, month after month, because a leader does not get to set a number like that down. Now, with the blessing in his mouth, he could not lift it onto their heads.

Levi Set the Cup Down

He had blessed Levi only a breath before. That was the cut inside the cut. Levi and Simeon had once been a matched pair, two sons, two swords.

Years before any of these listeners were born, the brothers had walked into Shechem with blades hidden and put every man of the city down while those men still lay weak from their own circumcision, payment for what had been done to their sister Dinah (Genesis 34:25). They had drunk from one cup of violence.

But Levi turned the blade. When Israel danced around the golden calf, the sons of Levi came back to Moses's side, and the priesthood was their wage. A Levite, Phinehas, later stopped the plague by killing a Simeonite prince in the act. Simeon kept the old fire and carried it into the Moabite tents. Two brothers, one cup, but only one of them set it down. So Levi received a blessing thick with priestly things, and Simeon received the worst thing a father can give a son, which is nothing at all.

He Hid Simeon Inside Judah

Moses came to Judah, and his voice changed. He was no longer only blessing the lion of the tribes, the root from which a king named David would rise. He was hiding something in the words.

"Hear, Lord, his voice," he prayed over Judah, looking past the river to a day when a shepherd boy would walk out alone toward a giant, and he asked that David's hands be enough in that hour and that he be brought home in peace (Deuteronomy 33:7). Folded into that same petition, so quietly the Simeonites never caught it, was their rescue. Let Judah's voice be heard every time Judah cries out for Simeon in distress. Let the lost tribe live inside the land of the lion, its inheritance cut from Judah's own portion, fed by Judah's prayers.

He would not say the name aloud, because the wound at Shittim was still too raw in his mouth. So he did the only thing a dying father could do for a son he could not bless and would not abandon. He hid the blessing where it would be safe, inside the blessing of the brother strong enough to carry it.

The Old Man Climbed Without the Name

The count on the man's fingers never closed. Eleven. The Simeonites stood in their knot after the last Amen, waiting for a correction that did not come. Moses wiped his hands on his robe as if oil were still on them, turned from the camp, and started up the mountain he would not come down from.

Behind him the tribes broke apart into their tents. Judah's people walked with a blessing still warm on their heads. Simeon's people walked with a hole where a name should have been. They did not know the hole had been filled in secret, stitched into another tribe's future, to be opened later by a voice crying out for a brother in trouble.

Moses climbed until the camp was only a smear of smoke. The river stayed at his back. He died with the secret kept.