The Evil Inclination Asked Who Fed God Before the Altar

Click for full size

The Whisper Beside the Eight-Day Calf

The calf was eight days old and walked badly. Twice on the ramp the man had to push a hand under its chest to keep it off the stones. Smoke from the dawn offering hung low over the court of God. It smelled of cedar and burnt fat.

Something climbed the ramp beside him carrying nothing.

"Who fed Him before you were born?" it asked.

The man kept climbing.

"Before Israel. Before there was a court, or a ramp, or a man with a calf under his arm. Who slaughtered for Him then? Who arranged His table?" The yetzer hara (יצר הרע), the evil inclination, never shouts. It waits until a man's arms are full. "If He ate then, somebody cooked for Him. If He did not eat then, why does He want this out of you now?"

The man had no answer. What he was given instead was a witness.

The Man of Bread Who Went Up Past the Clouds

Moses ate. He had eaten in Pharaoh's house off painted dishes and in Jethro's tent in Midian, and when he climbed into the cloud on Sinai his body came with him, appetites and all.

The cloud closed behind him.

On the first day his hand went out for bread from pure habit and closed on the fold of his own robe. There was no bread. No ovens above the firmament, no coals, no smell of anything roasting anywhere in that country of light. He listened for the sound a knife makes at a throat, the sound that filled every court in the world below at dawn, and heard nothing at all. The creatures around the Throne stood and sang and never once stopped to be fed.

Forty days. Then forty more. Then forty after those.

A hundred and twenty days in a place with no table. He neither ate bread nor drank water (Exodus 34:28), his knees did not buckle, and somewhere in that long stretch his stomach stopped asking, because there was nothing over the clouds for it to ask for. He came down with a face the people could not look at.

The Second Whisper and the Altar Nobody Built on Sinai

The evil inclination came back sharper, the way it always does.

"Grant that he starved gracefully up there. What of it? If there were no eating and drinking in front of Him, He would never have told you to cut a bull's throat and pour wine into a fire. Nobody orders a dinner he cannot swallow."

Rabbi Shimon ben Lakish put both hands flat on the table when he answered that one.

"The continual burnt offering instituted at Mount Sinai" (Numbers 28:6), he said. "So who offered sacrifices on Mount Sinai?"

Nobody answered, because no altar was ever raised on that mountain and no animal was ever dragged up its slope. The only thing that went up Sinai and came down again was a man.

"Go and ask Moses whether there was food and drink before the Holy One," Ben Lakish said. "And when he tells you there was none, ask why the daily offering was laid on your shoulders at all. It was laid there to do you good."

Water Enough for the World in One Cupped Hand

Rabbi Hiyya bar Abba made the same case with his hands.

He cupped them and held them out the way a big man does at a stream, thirsty, dust in his beard. "How much does he drink that way?" he asked. "Ten handfuls? Six? Four? Nobody swallows less than two." He tipped the empty water of his palms into his mouth and let the room watch a strong man's thirst.

Then he opened the other hand. "Who has measured the waters in the hollow of His hand?" (Isaiah 40:12). Every sea. The rain still standing in the clouds and the water sleeping under the earth. All of it lies in the hollow of one hand and does not fill it.

"A hand like that has never once been thirsty," he said. "So why the bull at dawn, why the wine on the fire? Not to feed Him. To do you good."

The Lamp Kindled Out of the Darkness on the Deep

At dusk Aaron stepped up in front of the lampstand with a burning wick in his fingers, because borrowing is the only way a man has ever made fire. Flame from flame. Lamp from lamp. One cup of the menorah (the lampstand) leaning its light into the next until all seven stood up and the walls went gold.

Nobody has ever kindled a lamp out of darkness.

There was a night with nothing to borrow from. Darkness lay on the face of the deep (Genesis 1:2), with no coal anywhere inside it, no spark, no second lamp to lean toward. God said, "Let there be light," and light came up out of the dark itself, struck from a lamp that had never been lit.

The voice that had done that came to Aaron while the wicks were still smoking. "Do I have need of your light?" it asked. "Set the lamp up continually (Exodus 27:20). It rises to lift you, not Me."

The Smoke That Nothing Leaned Down to Take

The man laid both hands on the calf's head and pressed down until the animal quieted under the weight. The knife went across. The blood ran into the basin, the basin went to the corner of the altar, and the fat went up in a smell that carried past the far gate.

The smoke bent east with the wind, thinned, and was gone before it cleared the wall.

Nothing above the wall leaned down to meet it. Nothing up there had ever been hungry, and the man walked back down the ramp with his hands empty and lighter than they had been since morning. Beside him, for the first time since he came through the gate, the voice had nothing left to say.