Parshat Bereshit5 min read

Eve Walked to Paradise to Save Adam and Was Tricked Again

Eve walked to the gates of Paradise for healing oil to save Adam. Satan met her on the road and tricked her a second time before she could arrive.

Curated by Arthur · Told by Maggid ·
Table of Contents
  1. The Dying Man's Request
  2. The Beast That Attacked Seth
  3. The Gates of Eden
  4. The Voice That Came Before They Arrived
  5. What Adam Heard

The Dying Man's Request

Adam lay on his bed in agony, the seventy-two afflictions gnawing at his body from the inside. He had lived for centuries after the expulsion, but the body God had shaped from the dust of seven continents was finally failing, and the pain was not quiet. It was loud, comprehensive, and relentless.

Eve wept beside him. "My lord Adam," she said, "rise up and give me half your suffering. Let me carry it. This happened because of me." But Adam would not hear of it. He was in too much pain to argue with her, so instead he gave her a mission.

"Go with our son Seth toward Paradise. Put earth on your heads. Weep and pray that God will have mercy on me and send His angel to the garden, to bring oil from the Tree of Life. If I can anoint myself with it, perhaps I will find rest from this agony."

So Eve and Seth set out together, walking back toward the place from which they had been cast out so long ago that the children of their children had lost count of the years.

The Beast That Attacked Seth

They were still far from Paradise when a wild beast came out of the brush and bit Seth. Eve screamed at it. "You wicked creature, how dare you attack the image of God? Do you not feel shame?" The beast pulled back, but it spoke. It said: "Eve. Is it not you who opened your mouth to eat the fruit? Is it not you who made yourself subject to every suffering? It is your fault, not mine, that I can do this."

Eve did not answer. She and Seth kept walking.

The Gates of Eden

When they reached the edge of Paradise, they knelt on the ground and wept, throwing dust on their heads as Adam had instructed. They cried out to God for mercy, for oil from the Tree of Life, for some relief from the dying man waiting for them back at the cave. They prayed with the kind of urgency that has no patience for form and simply pours itself out.

The archangel Michael appeared. He told them plainly: the oil they were asking for was not available yet. That tree, and its mercy, belonged to the age that would come after this one. When five thousand five hundred years had passed and the great resurrection took place, then the anointing oil would flow. Not before.

He gave them something else instead. A prophecy about what would happen to Adam, what would happen to his body, what God had in mind for the whole arc of creation. He told Seth to go back and tell his father to prepare himself, because in three days Adam would leave his body, and then they would know how God kept promises.

Seth and Eve turned back toward the cave.

The Voice That Came Before They Arrived

Somewhere on the road home, before they reached Adam, Eve heard a voice. She could not say afterward where it came from or whose it was. But it told her that she had failed. That she had gone all the way to Paradise and come back empty-handed. That Adam was suffering because of her, as the beast had said, and that she had proved incapable even of securing the one thing that might have helped him.

It was the same voice that had spoken through the serpent in the garden. Not identical in sound but identical in strategy: find the thing the woman already believes about herself, the deep shame she carries, and press on it. Eve had carried the weight of the expulsion for centuries. The voice found the wound and put its hand on it.

She believed it, at least for the length of the road home. She arrived at the cave carrying a prophecy and a sorrow that was not entirely hers to carry.

What Adam Heard

When Adam heard what Michael had said, he did not grieve the oil. He had suspected, somewhere in the failing of his body, that what he needed was not a remedy but a conclusion. He comforted Eve. He told her not to worry about who was to blame. They would die together soon enough, one after the other, and God had said He would not forget His own creation.

He gave her final instructions about how to prepare his body. Then he asked her to stand aside and pray while he gave up his spirit, so that his last moments were not clouded by her weeping.

She obeyed. She stood apart and prayed, the woman who had walked to the edge of Paradise and been turned away again, still doing what her husband asked, still trying in the only way left to her to be useful to the man she had loved across centuries of shared exile.


← All myths

From the tradition

Sources

3 sources

The texts this telling draws on, in full. Open a card to read inline, or expand it for a wider, quieter read.

Apocalypse of Moses 9-14Life of Adam and Eve

A dying man asked his wife and son to walk to the edge of Paradise and beg for mercy. They came back with a prophecy -- and a death sentence.

Adam lay groaning on his bed, the seventy-two afflictions gnawing at his body. He could barely speak. "What shall I do?" he whispered. "I am in great distress."

Eve wept. "My lord Adam, rise up and give me half your suffering. Let me carry it. This happened because of me. Because of me you are tormented." But Adam would not hear of it. Instead, he sent her on a mission.

"Go with our son Seth toward Paradise. Put earth on your heads. Weep and pray that God will have mercy on me and send His angel to the garden -- to bring oil from the Tree of Life. If I can anoint myself with it, perhaps I will find rest from this agony."

So Seth and Eve set out toward Eden.

On the road, a wild beast lunged at Seth. Eve screamed: "Woe is me! On the day of resurrection, every sinner will curse me, saying: 'Eve did not keep the commandment of God!'" She turned to the beast and challenged it: "You wicked creature -- do you not fear to fight with one made in the image of God? How dare you open your mouth against him? You were made subject to us long ago!"

The beast spoke back. It was no ordinary animal. "This is not our concern, Eve -- your greed and your wailing belong to you. It was because of you that the rule of beasts was overturned. How was your mouth opened to eat from the tree that God forbade? Our very nature was transformed because of what you did. Do not blame us if we rise against you."

Seth silenced the beast with a single command: "Close your mouth. Stand off from the image of God until the Day of Judgment." And the beast obeyed. It bowed and slunk back to its lair.

Mother and son pressed on. They reached the gates of Paradise and knelt in the dust, weeping and praying for the Oil of Mercy.

God sent the archangel Michael. But Michael did not bring oil.

"Seth, man of God," Michael said, "do not exhaust yourself with prayers for the tree that flows with oil to anoint your father Adam. It shall not be given to you now. Only at the end of days. Then all flesh shall be raised -- from Adam to the last of the holy people. Then the delights of Paradise will be restored to them, and God will dwell in their midst. The evil inclination will be removed from their hearts, and they will be given a heart that understands only good and serves God alone."

A promise. Magnificent. But distant.

"Go back to your father," Michael continued. "The term of his life is fulfilled. He will live only three more days, and then he will die. When his soul departs, you will behold the terrifying scene of his passing."

The angel vanished. Seth and Eve returned to the hut where Adam lay. When he saw their faces, he knew. They had failed.

Adam turned to Eve. "What have you done to us? You have brought upon us a great wrath -- death itself, lording it over our entire race." Then his voice softened with one final request: "Call all our children and our children's children together. Tell them the manner of our transgression. Tell them everything."

Three days. That was all he had left. And in those three days, the whole story would have to be told.

Full source
Apocalypse of Moses 30-34Life of Adam and Eve

A dying man's last request was simple: pray for me. What happened next was something no human eye had ever seen.

"Guard yourselves from transgressing against the good."

While she spoke, Adam lay in the next room, bound to die within a single day. The sickness had fastened onto him and would not let go. Eve went to him and asked the question every wife dreads: "How is it that you die and I live? How long must I endure after you are gone?"

Adam comforted her. "Do not worry about this. You will not be long after me. We will both die together. When I die, anoint me, but let no one touch my body until the angel of the Lord speaks concerning me. God will not forget me. He will seek out His own creation." Then he gave her one final instruction: "Arise and pray to God while I give up my spirit into the hands of the One who gave it to me. For we do not know how we will meet our Maker -- whether He will be wrathful, or merciful enough to pity and receive us."

Eve rose, went outside, and fell on the ground. She began to pray -- not gently, not quietly, but with the raw desperation of a woman who had broken the world and knew it.

"I have sinned, O God. I have sinned, O God of All. I have sinned against You. I have sinned against the chosen angels. I have sinned against the Cherubim. I have sinned against Your fearful and unshakable Throne. I have sinned before You, and all sin began through me in the creation."

While she was still on her knees, an angel appeared and raised her to her feet. "Rise up, Eve, from your penitence. Your husband Adam has gone out of his body. Rise and behold his spirit being carried aloft to his Maker."

Eve stood. She wiped the tears from her face. The angel said: "Lift yourself from the earth and look."

She gazed steadfastly into the sky. And what she saw was beyond anything she could have imagined.

A chariot of light, carried by four brilliant eagles -- so radiant that no mortal born of woman could describe their glory or bear to look upon them. Angels processed before the chariot, and when it reached the place where Adam's body lay, it halted. The Seraphim surrounded it. Golden censers appeared between Adam's body and the chariot. Every angel carried censers and frankincense, and they blew upon the incense until the smoke veiled the very firmament.

Then the angels fell on their faces before God, crying out: "Ja'el, Holy One -- have mercy, for he is Your image, the work of Your holy hands!"

Eve beheld two great and terrifying figures standing in the presence of God. She wept with fear and cried out to her son Seth: "Rise up from the body of your father Adam and come to me. You must see this. No human eye has ever witnessed what is happening now."

The first man was dying. And all of Heaven had come to watch.

Full source
Apocalypse of Moses 24-29Life of Adam and Eve

God pronounced three curses. One for the man. One for the woman. One for the serpent. And with those three curses, the world as it had been ended forever.

To Adam, God said: "Since you disregarded My commandment and listened to your wife -- cursed is the earth because of you. You will work the soil and it will not yield its strength. Thorns and thistles will spring up for you. By the sweat of your face you will eat bread (Genesis 3:17-19). You will toil without end. You will be crushed by bitterness but taste no sweetness. You will be weary and find no rest. Scorched by heat, frozen by cold. You will labor endlessly but never grow rich. The beasts that once obeyed you will rise in rebellion -- because you did not keep My commandment."

To Eve, the Lord said: "Since you listened to the serpent and turned a deaf ear to My word -- you will know the agony of childbirth. You will bear children in trembling, and in a single hour you will come to the edge of death from the pain. But you will cry out: 'Lord, Lord, save me, and I will never return to the sin of the flesh!' And from your own words I will judge you, because of the enmity the Adversary has planted in you."

Then God turned to the serpent in great wrath. "Since you have done this -- since you became a thankless vessel and deceived innocent hearts -- cursed are you above all beasts. You will eat dust all the days of your life. On your belly you will crawl, stripped of hands and feet. Not a single limb will remain of what you used to ensnare them. And I will place enmity between you and the woman's offspring -- he will crush your head, and you will strike at his heel, until the Day of Judgment" (Genesis 3:14-15).

The sentences delivered, God commanded the angels to drive Adam and Eve from Paradise. As they were being pushed out -- weeping, wailing, their voices echoing across the garden -- Adam begged the angels: "Wait. Give me just a moment to pray. Let me entreat the Lord for compassion. I alone have sinned."

The angels paused. Adam fell to his knees and wept: "Pardon me, O Lord, for what I have done."

But God spoke to the angels: "Why have you stopped driving him out? Is it I who have done wrong? Is My judgment unjust?" The angels dropped to the ground in worship: "You are just, O Lord. Your judgment is righteous."

God turned back to Adam. "I will not allow you to remain in Paradise."

Adam made one last plea: "Grant me, Lord, just a taste from the Tree of Life before I am cast out."

"You will not take from it now," God replied. "I have stationed the Cherubim with a flaming sword to guard it from you (Genesis 3:24). But hear this -- the Adversary has planted war inside you. If you keep yourself from evil after you leave this place, if you live as one who knows he must die, then when the Resurrection comes, I will raise you up. And the Tree of Life will be given to you at last."

A promise. Conditional, distant, but real.

The Lord ordered the expulsion to proceed. Adam stood weeping before the angels, facing Paradise one final time. "You are casting me out," he said. "At least allow me to take fragrant herbs, so that I may offer sacrifices to God from outside the garden and He might still hear me."

The angels brought the request before God. "Ja'el, Eternal King," they said, "command that Adam be given incense and seeds for his survival."

God granted it. Adam re-entered Paradise one last time -- not as its guardian, but as a beggar. He took four precious spices: crocus, nard, calamus, and cinnamon. He gathered seeds for food. Then he walked out through the gates.

The garden closed behind him. And Adam and Eve stood on the bare earth, alone, holding nothing but a handful of spices and the fading memory of glory.

Full source